Friday, March 09, 2018

Autopsy reports -- still waiting for clarification

Last May, I posted a discussion concerning the treatment of autopsy reports under the Confrontation Clause.  The principal issue is when, or whether, such reports should be considered testimonial.  A secondary issue, which arises in other contexts, is whether, assuming a report is testimonial, the prosecution can present secondary evidence concerning the contents of the report on the ground that it supports the opinion of an expert testifying live at trial.

I think the answers should be clear:  An autopsy report should clearly be considered testimonial when it concludes that the probable cause of death is homicide or otherwise provides evidence that a reasonable person in the position of the person writing the report would realize would likely be used in prosecution.  And if a report is testimonial, the Confrontation Clause is not satisfied by having an in-court witness rely on the report  for her opinion, whether or not that opinion is characterized as "independent," if the report only supports the opinion on the premise that the report is truthful.

But unfortunately there remains a great deal of confusion on these issues in the lower courts.  Some get them right, and others do not.  The Supreme Court indicated some interest in the problem last fall when it asked for a brief in opposition to the petition for certiorari (in which Jeff Fisher participated) in Garlick v. New York, but in the end it denied the petition.  Here are the petition (together with the motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis) and the reply brief in support of the petition.

Meanwhile, Cody Reaves, who has since graduated from the University of Michigan Law School, did an independent study under my supervision on the Confrontation Clause issues related to the use of autopsy reports.  I believe his memo is a very useful resource for anyone doing research in this area, so I am posting it here.  It is Cody's work, not mine, and the conclusions are his; I certainly agree with some of his opinions, but not necessarily with all.

19 comments:

pv said...

The Court's upcoming opinion in Hughes regarding the Marks rule might have a big impact on the precedential value of Williams v. Illinois and, in turn, whether autopsy reports are testimonial.

Depending upon whether the opinion of the Williams plurality, concurrence or dissent can provide guidance to lower courts, that will impact the CC autopsy report question. And that depends on what the Court does in Hughes, if anything, regarding the Marks rule.

Steven Yermish said...

Here in Florida we have a real issue; two different intermediate appellate courts have come to opposite conclusions on the issue in the Banmah and Rosario opinions. While the Supreme Court, in dicta, has seemingly opined that an autopsy report is not testimonial, I do not believe there is anything binding. Thus, it all depends on where your client decides to commit the homicide. I just had a judge in a murder trial here in Miami rule against me on the issue, holding that the report is not testimonial based on Banmah (binding precedent in our circuit) although he openly acknowledged the Rosario decision made more sense and he would otherwise embrace that holding. So much for stare decisis supporting consistency!

pv said...

Steven, whether an autopsy report is testimonial depends upon whether a court applies the Williams plurality's "accusatory purpose" test, the concurring "formality" test, or the dissent's "evidentiary purpose" test.

That's why the Supreme Court's opinion in the upcoming Hughes case (determining the validity and scope of the Marks rule) is so important to determining what, if any, precedential weight should be accorded the fractured Williams case.

Jasa Fotocopy Murah Jakarta said...

Saya dari indonesia sangat senang sekali membaca di artikel anda

Anonymous said...

Opinion last week from PA Supreme Court on this issue.

Lina Tan said...

Ayo Kakak Semuanya,
Yuk iseng bermain game untuk mendapatkan uang tambahan setiap harinya Hanya di HobiQQ.
Modal Kecil Dapat Puluhan Juta ^^
Bareng aku dan teman-temanku yang cantik-cantik loh !
Info Situs HobiQQ :
BBM : DD09567B
WA : +6281262400720
LINE : hobi-qq
Facebook : Lina Tan


Kunjungi Juga :
Agen Bandarq
Agen Bandarq Online
Agen Dominoqq
Agen Domino99
Agen Poker Terbaik
Situs Bandarq Online
Judi Online Terbesar
Artikel Unik dan Menarik
Hobi Baca Artikel
Artikel Menarik
Cerita Dewasa Terlengkap

Agen Togel Online Terpercaya Di Indonesia said...

Thanks for a marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you happen to be a great author. I will remember to bookmark your blog and will often come back at some point. I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great writing, have a nice day! my blog post
http://dewamimpi4d.com/
dewamimpi4d

tangkas asia said...

this is very helpful, thank you
tangkas asia

yessy haryanto said...

Haloo pak^^

Kami dari SENTANAPOKER ingin menawarkan pak^^

Untuk saat ini kami menerima Deposit Melalui Pulsa ya pak.

*untuk minimal deposit 10ribu
*untuk minimal Withdraw 25ribu

*untuk deposit pulsa kami menerima provider
-XL
-Telkomsel


untuk bonus yang kami miliki kami memiliki
*bonus cashback 0,5%
*bunus refferal 20%
*bonus gebiar bulanan (N-max,samsung Note 10+,Iphone xr 64G,camera go pro 7hero,Apple airpods 2 ,dan freechips)

Daftar Langsung Di:

SENTANAPOKER

Kontak Kami;

WA : +855 9647 76509
Line : SentanaPoker
Wechat : SentanaPokerLivechat Sentanapoker

Proses deposit dan withdraw tercepat bisa anda rasakan jika bermain di Sentanapoker. So… ? tunggu apa lagi ? Mari bergabung dengan kami. Pelayanan CS yang ramah dan Proffesional dan pastinya sangat aman juga bisa anda dapatkan di Sentanapoker.

Situs Judi Online Terpercaya said...

NAGAQQ: AGEN BANDARQ BANDARQ ONLINE ADUQ ONLINE DOMINOQQ TERBAIK

Yang Merupakan Agen Bandarq, Domino 99, Dan Bandar Poker Online Terpercaya di asia hadir untuk anda semua dengan permainan permainan menarik dan bonus menarik untuk anda semua

Bonus yang diberikan NagaQQ :
* Bonus rollingan 0.5%,setiap senin di bagikannya
* Bonus Refferal 10% + 10%,seumur hidup
* Bonus Jackpot, yang dapat anda dapatkan dengan mudah
* Minimal Depo 15.000
* Minimal WD 20.000

Memegang Gelar atau title sebagai Agen BandarQ Terbaik di masanya

Games Yang di Hadirkan NagaQQ :
* Poker Online
* BandarQ
* Domino99
* Bandar Poker
* Bandar66
* Sakong
* Capsa Susun
* AduQ
* Perang Bacarrat (New Game)

Tersedia Deposit Via pulsa :
Telkomsel & XL

Info Lebih lanjut Kunjungi :
Website : NagaQQ
Facebook : NagaQQ Official
Kontakk : Info NagaQQ
linktree : Agen Judi Online
WHATSAPP : +855977509035
Line : Cs_nagaQQ
TELEGRAM : +855967014811


BACA JUGA BLOGSPORT KAMI YANG LAIN:
agen bandarq terbaik
Winner NagaQQ
Daftar NagaQQ
Agen Poker Online

VANIA GEMAS said...

MiyaQQ merupakan Situs Judi Poker Pkv yang sangat di gemari oleh para pencinta judi online. karena di MiyaQQ anda bisa merasakan permainan yang benar benar murni fair play. MiyaQQ menjamin kemurnian akan permainan yang telah di sediakan. Jika di temukan ada nya robot uang kembali 100%. DAFTAR SEKARANG !!! rasakan jackpot ratusan juta menjadi milik anda.

CrownQQ Agen DominoQQ BandarQ dan Domino99 Online Terbesar said...

CrownQQ Agen DominoQQ BandarQ dan Domino99 Online Terbesar

Yuk Buruan ikutan bermain di website CrownQQ
Sekarang CROWNQQ Memiliki Game terbaru Dan Ternama loh...

9 permainan :
=> Poker
=> Bandar Poker
=> Domino99
=> BandarQ
=> AduQ
=> Sakong
=> Capsa Susun
=> Bandar 66
=> Perang Baccarat (NEW GAME)

=> Bonus Refferal 20%
=> Bonus Turn Over 0,5%
=> Minimal Depo 20.000
=> Minimal WD 20.000
=> 100% Member Asli
=> Pelayanan DP & WD 24 jam
=> Livechat Kami 24 Jam Online
=> Bisa Dimainkan Di Hp Android
=> Di Layani Dengan 5 Bank Terbaik
=> 1 User ID 9 Permainan Menarik
=> Menyediakan deposit Via Pulsa Telkomsel & XL

Link Resmi CrownQQ:
- crownqq01.com
- crownqq01.net
- crownqq01.org

Info Lebih lanjut Kunjungi :
Website : CrownQQ
Daftar CrownQQ : Poker Online
Info CrownQQ : Kontakk
Linktree : Agen Poker Online

WHATSAPP : +6287771354805
Line : CS_CROWNQQ
Facebook : CrownQQ Official
Kemenangan CrownQQ : Agen BandarQ

Rajabandarq said...

Mau Dapatkan Uang Dengan Mudah...
Yuk join bersama Rajabandarq Situs Bandarq, DominoQQ, Poker Online terbaik di asia dengan 9 game yang paling seru...

Buruan Daftar Disini >>> Daftar Rajabandarq
Klik Disini : Situs BandarQ
Klik Disini : Poker Online

Baca juga :

- Blogger : 24berita harian
- Blogger : Kisahselebindo
- Blogger : myrenew22
- Blogger : Panduan Bermain Game Judi Online
- Blogger : Seputar Dunia

MEJAQQ said...

MEJAQQ: AGEN JUDI POKER DOMINOQQ BANDARQ ONLINE TERBESAR DI ASIA

Yang Merupakan Agen Judi Poker DominoQQ BandarQ Online Terbesar di Asia Hadir Untuk Anda Semua Dengan Games dan Bonus Yang Menarik!

Bonus yang Kami Berikan di MEJAQQ :
* Bonus Rollingan 0.5% Kali 2
* Bonus Referral 10% + 10% Seumur Hidup (X-tra Untuk Para Pencari Bonus Referral di Indonesia)
* Dan Masih Banyak Bonus Menarik Lainnya yang Bisa Anda Dapatkan di MEJAQQ!
*Dan Kami Juga Menyediakan Deposit Pulsa Tanpa Adanya Potongan Pulsa!
Buruan Kunjungi Sekarang Juga ^^

9 Games Yang di Hadirkan MEJAQQ:
*- POKER
*- DOMINO QQ
*- CAPSA SUSUN
*- BANDAR POKER
*- BANDAR Q
*- BANDAR 66
*- SAKONG
*- ADU Q
*- PERANG BACCARAT

Info Lebih lanjut Kunjungi :
Website : Mejayes(.)org
Line : Mejaqq_official
WA 1 : +85515620767
TELEGRAM : +85515620767

Kunjungi Juga situs kami di :
MEJAQQ
MEJAYES
BANDARQ ONLINE
QQ ONLINE
Informasi Terbaru
SITUS BANDARQ

Rajabandarq said...

Mau Dapatkan Uang Dengan Mudah...
Yuk join bersama Rajabandarq Situs Bandarq, DominoQQ, Poker Online terbaik di asia dengan 9 game yang paling seru...

Buruan Daftar Disini >>> Daftar Rajabandarq
Klik Disini : Situs BandarQ
Klik Disini : Poker Online

Baca juga :

- Blogger : 24berita harian
- Blogger : Kisahselebindo
- Blogger : myrenew22
- Blogger : Panduan Bermain Game Judi Online
- Blogger : Seputar Dunia

MEJAQQ said...

MEJAQQ: AGEN JUDI POKER DOMINOQQ BANDARQ ONLINE TERBESAR DI ASIA

Yang Merupakan Agen Judi Poker DominoQQ BandarQ Online Terbesar di Asia Hadir Untuk Anda Semua Dengan Games dan Bonus Yang Menarik!

Bonus yang Kami Berikan di MEJAQQ :
* Bonus Rollingan 0.5% Kali 2
* Bonus Referral 10% + 10% Seumur Hidup (X-tra Untuk Para Pencari Bonus Referral di Indonesia)
* Dan Masih Banyak Bonus Menarik Lainnya yang Bisa Anda Dapatkan di MEJAQQ!
*Dan Kami Juga Menyediakan Deposit Pulsa Tanpa Adanya Potongan Pulsa!
Buruan Kunjungi Sekarang Juga ^^

9 Games Yang di Hadirkan MEJAQQ:
*- POKER
*- DOMINO QQ
*- CAPSA SUSUN
*- BANDAR POKER
*- BANDAR Q
*- BANDAR 66
*- SAKONG
*- ADU Q
*- PERANG BACCARAT

Info Lebih lanjut Kunjungi :
Website : Mejayes(.)org
Line : Mejaqq_official
WA 1 : +85515620767
TELEGRAM : +85515620767

Kunjungi Juga situs kami di :
MEJAQQ
MEJAYES
BANDARQ ONLINE
QQ ONLINE
Informasi Terbaru
SITUS BANDARQ

muslera said...

Erkek spor ayakkabı arayanlar için liste:

1: erkek spor ayakkabı

2: erkek spor ayakkabı

3: erkek spor ayakkabı

4: erkek spor ayakkabı

5: erkek spor ayakkabı

6: erkek spor ayakkabı

jasonbob said...

off white
golden goose
moncler jackets
golden goose
kyrie 7
hermes
jordan shoes
bape
off white
curry 6

LOADED ATM CARDS WITH VSPW W.W.W said...

Much obliged for tolerating me on your blog. I will carry numerous different bloggers to get your RSS roots to get more educated by your connected articles.
I tumble on a rundown of clinical affirmations courses on the web and I have chosen to impart to you the uplifting news since I realize many individuals are looking for occupations on the web, this might assist many individuals with getting utilized straightforwardly abroad.
We have examples of ATTACHED MEDICAL CERTIFICATION COURSES you can use these to get your job abroad, I will also take the advantage to ask for your permission to join our 179.3k members TELEGRAM GROUP
to share with us your ideas or any latest update on your blog.
Thanks I am Scott from Globex, we are expecting you on our platform.