Monday, May 04, 2020

Remote testimony and the coronavirus crisis


The coronavirus crisis has created increased interest in the subject of remote testimony – testimony in which the witness is not in the courtroom but rather testifies from a remote location, with the testimony electronically transmitted to the courtroom.  I hope courts will not use the crisis as an occasion for undermining the confrontation right, even temporarily – especially because, as I will explain, there is a rather simple solution in this setting.

I wrote at length some years ago about remote testimony in a law review article.  And, as it happens, in early March (while courts were still holding ordinary sessions) I participated, as amicus, in an argument on the subject in the Michigan Supreme Court in People v. Jemison.  You can see the main briefs of the parties, and my amicus brief, here.  (The video of the argument is available here.)  My amicus brief lays out my general views on the subject.

In sum, though Maryland v. Craig allowed remote testimony by children in cases of demonstrated trauma, Craig is in tension with Crawford, which was decided afterwards, and should not be extended, especially by lower courts.  The Supreme Court declined to transmit to Congress a proposed amendment to the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure that would have allowed for remote testimony in some cases; Justice Scalia, writing in support of that decision, explained that “virtual confrontation” did not appear to satisfy the confrontation right.  I don’t believe there is any need to take an absolute stand that virtual confrontation will never be deemed acceptable for adult witnesses.  But at this point I don’t believe that we are close to having enough scientific knowledge to be confident that virtual confrontation is an adequate substitute for taking testimony the traditional way.  And if it is to be allowed, it should only be in cases of compelling need (Jemison does not come close), and only under a careful protocol that ensures satisfactory technical specifications and also proper procedures with respect to such matters as how much may be seen and who may be in the room with the witness.

Now, how about the current crisis?  Here, the impetus for remote testimony is not to protect the witness from trauma (as under Craig), or to save time and money, or that for some reason, such as a witness who is desperately ill or beyond the subpoena power, it appears difficult or unfeasible to bring the witness to the courtroom.  Rather, here the consideration is the necessity of keeping people a sufficient distance apart.  But to satisfy the confrontation right, it is not necessary that the witness be in a full courtroom.  All that is required is that the witness, the defendant, and defense counsel be in the same room when the witness testifies; presumably the prosecutor would want to be as well.  Perhaps a videographer would be as well, though that might not be necessary.  And it would not be necessary that the judge be in the room; a remote hookup should suffice, and in fact even that would not be absolutely essential.  It has long been established that when the witness cannot be brought to the courtroom, a deposition, at which the accused has had an opportunity for confrontation, is sufficient, and Crawford maintains this rule.  Getting the witness to the defendant, or the defendant and counsel to the witness, does involve some transportation, but most witnesses in criminal cases do not live far from defendants, and this should not be a major consideration, even under current conditions, though one could imagine that in an occasional case it might make sense to postpone the trial for a few months.

In most jurisdictions, depositions in a criminal case are relatively rare.  But this is an occasion on which they ought to be held routinely.

20 comments:

Paul Ksicinski said...

Thank you for sharing this detailed examination. It is very useful. I have a question. I know this is a confrontation blog up, but I wonder about preserving the right to confrontation at the expense of the right to effective assistance of counsel. My concern about effective assistance of counsel stems from how effective is an attorney in confronting a witness when the attorney is barred from watching and responding to the jury react to questions on cross-examination? Or if this were extended from cross examination to a whole trial to include attorney conducted voir dire? While voir dire involves overt questions to the jury, during cross examination are not some of counsel's questions shaped not only by verbal statements of a witness but also reactions from the jury which are not possible for counsel to read if counsel is off in another room from the jury?

Situs Judi Poker Terpercaya said...

https://lazytech.online/

Situs Judi Poker Terpercaya said...

https://lazygames.online/

Situs Judi Poker Terpercaya said...

daftar domino qq online

Situs Judi Poker Terpercaya said...

dadu online terpercaya

Situs Judi Poker Terpercaya said...

casino dragon tiger

Situs Judi Poker Terpercaya said...

casino nova88

Situs Judi Poker Terpercaya said...

daftar domino qq online

Situs Judi Poker Terpercaya said...

judi ceme online

Situs Judi Poker Terpercaya said...

judi ceme online

Yuliana Wijaya said...

MEJAQQ: AGEN JUDI POKER DOMINOQQ BANDARQ ONLINE TERBESAR DI ASIA

Yang Merupakan Agen Judi Poker DominoQQ BandarQ Online Terbesar di Asia Hadir Untuk Anda Semua Dengan Games dan Bonus Yang Menarik!

Bonus yang Kami Berikan di MEJAQQ :
* Bonus CASHBACK 0,5% (Dibagikan setiap hari SENIN)
* Bonus REFERRAL 10% + 10% SEUMUR HIDUP (Total kemenangan REFERRAL anda)
* Minimal Deposit 20,000
* Minimal Withdraw 20,000
* 7 Bank Lokal (BCA, BNI, MANDIRI, BRI, DANAMON, CIMB NIAGA, PERMATA)
* Deposit via E-Money, Pulsa XL dan TELKOMSEL
* 100% Member vs Member
* Pelayanan Bank dan Livechat 24 jam
* Tersedia Dalam Aplikasi Android atau IOS.

Mau dapet duit tanpa kerja? Bisa banget!
Caranya? Buruan Kunjungi Sekarang Juga ^.^

Info Lebih Lanjut :
WA 1 : +855975482150
WA 2 : +855978975095

Kunjungi situs kami di :
MEJAQQ
BandarQ Online
Agen BandarQ Online

BLOGSPOT :
DUNIA VIRAL
DUNIA MOVIE
DUNIA GAME
DUNIA ANIME

Sahabat303 said...

"""Perkenalkan kita Sahabat303 Agen Sabung Ayam, Agen Bola Terpercaya, Casino Online, Slot Games.
Dengan pendaftaran gratis dan mudah tentunya.
Hanya dengan Minimal Deposit 50 ribu anda sudah bisa bermain dan menikmati Berbagai Bonus Menarik Dari Sahabat303 Berikut Ini :

» Bonus Deposit 10% Khusus Sportbook
» Bonus Deposit 10% Khusus Bola Tangkas
» Bonus Rollingan Live Casino 0,7%
» Bonus Cashback Casino Games 2%
» Bonus Cashback Sabung Ayam 5 - 10%
» Bonus Cashback Sportbook 6 - 16%
» Bonus Refferal 2%

Moto kita »
Kemenangan berapa pun pasti kita bayar lunas.

Untuk Info Lebih Lanjut Silahkan Hubungi Kami Melalui :
* LIVE CHAT TERSEDIA , LAYANAN 24 JAM NONSTOP
* Website : Sahabat303
* LINE : sahabat_303
* WA 1 : +855882348077
* WA 2 : +6287705585269
* Telegram : @sahabat303
* FB : Sahabat303

DAFTAR SITUS JUDI ONLINE TERPERCAYA
Agen Sabung Ayam
Agen Bola
Agen Bandarq
Agen Togel Online"""

yessy haryanto said...

Haloo pak^^

Kami dari SENTANAPOKER ingin menawarkan pak^^

Untuk saat ini kami menerima Deposit Melalui Pulsa ya pak.

*untuk minimal deposit 10ribu
*untuk minimal Withdraw 25ribu

*untuk deposit pulsa kami menerima provider
-XL
-Telkomsel


untuk bonus yang kami miliki kami memiliki
*bonus cashback 0,5%
*bunus refferal 20%
*bonus gebiar bulanan (N-max,samsung Note 10+,Iphone xr 64G,camera go pro 7hero,Apple airpods 2 ,dan freechips)

Daftar Langsung Di:

SENTANAPOKER

Kontak Kami;

WA : +855 9647 76509
Line : SentanaPoker
Wechat : SentanaPokerLivechat Sentanapoker

Proses deposit dan withdraw tercepat bisa anda rasakan jika bermain di Sentanapoker. So… ? tunggu apa lagi ? Mari bergabung dengan kami. Pelayanan CS yang ramah dan Proffesional dan pastinya sangat aman juga bisa anda dapatkan di Sentanapoker.

Agen Slot Online said...

Salam Admin, bagus informasinya sangat bermanfaat. Lanjutkan terus artikel penuh wawasan seperti ini.
Kami Dari Agen Betting Online Terpercaya QQicon188.
Agen Slot Games
Agen Casino Online
Agen Bola Terpercaya
Bandar Bola
Agen Poker Terpercaya
Agen Poker Online
Hormat Kami, Terima Kasih
Salam Admin, bagus informasinya sangat bermanfaat. Lanjutkan terus artikel penuh wawasan seperti ini.
Kami Dari Agen Betting Online Terpercaya QQicon188.
Agen Slot Games
Agen Casino Online
Agen Bola Terpercaya
Bandar Bola
Agen Poker Terpercaya
Agen Poker Online
Hormat Kami, Terima Kasih

Slot Games Online said...

Salam Admin, bagus informasinya sangat bermanfaat. Lanjutkan terus artikel penuh wawasan seperti ini.
Kami dari Game Jud1 Onl1ne Visitorbet Terpercaya . Jangan Segan untuk Bergabung bersama kami.
Agen Slot Games
Agen Casino Online
Agen Bola Terpercaya
Bandar Bola
Agen Poker Terpercaya
Agen Poker Online
Hormat Kami, Terima Kasih

Agen Slot Games said...

Salam Admin, bagus informasinya sangat bermanfaat. Lanjutkan terus artikel penuh wawasan seperti ini.
BAgi yang mau bermain sihlakan kunjungi inplay888
Ada banyak permainan yang pasti belom anda cobak
Agen Slot Games
Agen Casino Online
Agen Bola Terpercaya
Bandar Bola
Agen Poker Terpercaya
Agen Poker Online
Agen Tembak Ikan
Hormat Kami, Terima Kasih

ppowertv.com said...

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 스포츠중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 무료스포츠중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 해외축구중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 해외스포츠중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL KBO중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL K리그중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 한국프로야구중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 대만농구중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 러시아하키중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 중국롤LPL중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 동남아롤PCS중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 코로나중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL LCK중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 스포츠티비

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 스포츠분석

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 스포츠분석사이트

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 해외스포츠분석

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL nba중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 느바중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL mlb중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 믈브중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 해외농구중계

Free Sports Live Streaming Tv Soccer Basketball Football Baseball Volleyball Pingpong Tennis LOL 무료농구중계

Unknown said...

There should be no issue with an expert witness giving evidence remotely, especially in the current midst of a pandemic.
Here is the best source of expert witnesses I found: https://www.witnessdirectory.com

Gaurav Sharma said...

Good blog informatve for readers such a nice content keep posting thanks for sharing
Best Hotel in Mussoorie
business news in hindi
CHOPTA – “Mini Switzerland of Uttrakhand"
TOP 20 HILL STATIONS OF INDIA

CrownQQ Agen BandarQ said...

CrownQQ Agen DominoQQ BandarQ dan Domino99 Online Terbesar
Daftar CrownQQ